
HARRISBURG – Sen. Gene Yaw (R-23), chair of the Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee, responded to PennFuture and Conservation Voters of PA’s new environmental agenda that would raise costs for Pennsylvania ratepayers and drive employers away from the commonwealth:
“Pennsylvanians did not vote to advance the aggressive climate and renewable-mandate policies that have already driven higher costs and tighter reliability margins in New York, New Jersey and Maryland. Climate change was not a leading issue at the polls. Affordability and keeping the lights on were. The agenda claims to deliver lower bills, stronger reliability and economic benefits. A closer look at its core elements shows the opposite.
“The groups argue expanding solar, wind and battery storage is the best path to lower electricity prices and create union jobs. Pennsylvania’s actual generation mix tells a different story. Nuclear, natural gas and coal together supply roughly 95% of the commonwealth’s electricity. In-state wind and solar generate only about 2%, and expanding these intermittent resources only creates temporary installation work at best. It won’t replace the family-sustaining jobs associated with Pennsylvania’s leading electricity-generating industries. Battery storage is also not a substitute for that reliability and is not a one-size-fits-all solution.
“The agenda calls for strict guardrails so data centers are powered by wind and solar. In practice, this would be a moratorium on new data centers in Pennsylvania. If that’s the case and the only acceptable supply is intermittent generation, then companies would be more inclined to locate to West Virginia or Ohio, where reliable, round-the-clock generation remains welcome. Pennsylvania would lose out on major employment and economic opportunities and its position as a major net electricity exporter would be threatened.
“Additionally, community solar and expanded rooftop solar proposals that don’t reform net metering simply shift costs from higher-income suburban households to everyone else. Through net metering, those households are paid higher retail rates, not the lower wholesale rates every other generator receives for the power they send back to the grid. The difference is made up by other ratepayers. Lower-income households and renters, who cannot afford rooftop solar or are prohibited from installing it, end up paying more to subsidize systems owned by households that least need the help. This is not a progressive policy. It is a regressive transfer that the organizations advancing it rarely acknowledge.
“The agenda also calls for the passage of Gov. Josh Shapiro’s PRESS proposal, which would increase the Alternative Energy Portfolio Standards (AEPS) Tier I mandate from requiring 8% of electricity retail sales to come from intermittent sources like solar and wind to 35%, raising the annual cost on Pennsylvanians from $350 million last year to roughly $1.5 billion. Unlike Tier I, Tier II, which includes waste coal, hydropower and more, at least delivers reliable, baseload-capable generation that can help protect the grid. Expanding a mandate forcing Pennsylvania to purchase large volumes of out-of-state intermittent power transfers money to our neighbors for resources that are unreliable when demand is highest.
“PennFuture and Conservation Voters of PA receive most of their funding from large foundations, including the Heinz Endowments and Rockefeller-linked entities such as the Energy Foundation. Ratepayers and reporters should keep this in mind when evaluating claims that the agenda is driven solely by concern for working families.
“Pennsylvania’s existing nuclear, natural gas and coal fleet is the reason the commonwealth remains a major net exporter of electricity. Policies that raise costs, reduce capacity, discriminate against that fleet and shift expenses from wealthy suburban solar owners to lower-income households will not deliver the affordable, reliable power Pennsylvania needs.”
